Thursday, October 13, 2011

1972 Topps Baseball #5, John Bateman

This set holds a special place in my heart for its disco-style borders, dizzying color combos, and standout roster of players: Aaron, Mays, and Bench in the NL, with Reggie, Yaz, and Carew in the AL, to name but a few.

The logos remind me specifically of Schoolhouse Rock! cartoons, which an advertising team pitched in 1972. Safe to say my childhood would be totally different without baseball cards and those Grammar Rock episodes.


With those borders, jacket, jersey, hat, gloves, and teeth, John's card has more shades of white than Home Depot's paint aisle. That's about 5 full rooms of white, two coats each. (Wonder if there's a pack of cigarettes in that rolled-up jacket sleeve? And is it another shade of white?)


Not many guys hit multiple grand slams in a year. The single-season leaders are Travis Hafner (2006) and Don Mattingly (1987), who both hit 6. No one in 1971 hit more than 2, so John co-led the National League with Willie Stargell. It's not hard to find Bateman's slams in the batting log, since you'll get at least 4 RBIs out of it.
Both homers came with two outs, pretty dramatic moments for any guy's career.

Like many catchers at 30, John was just about done behind the plate. Montreal traded him to Philly mid-season for 77 games of Tim McCarver, another guy on his last legs in catching gear. Bateman retired after 1972 and McCarver spent his remaining years as a part-time player for Boston, St. Louis, and back again in Philadelphia, even playing six games (and collecting his final hit, a double) for 1980's first title winner.

Value: 1972 singles cost about a quarter.

Fakes / reprints: Topps reprinted several 1972 stars as inserts into modern sets. Look for a glossy finish and gold foil to distinguish reprints from originals.

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

1971 Topps Baseball #5, Thurman Munson

Most vintage collectors count this #5 as one of the best cards ever and I agree; here are five reasons why.
  • Standout horizontal shot in Topps first set with action photos
  • Outstanding play at the plate in a cloud of dust
  • Munson's own story as Yankee captain and MVP
  • Oakland's gold-and-green stirrups and jersey
  • Topps All-Star rookie trophy and nice autograph


Thanks to Card Corner, we know the guy sliding is Oakland pitcher Chuck Dobson. Read its article for full details, including Dobson's own place in history as Reggie Jackson's road trip roommate.


Since the card back mentions both the AL Rookie of the Year and Topps own Rookie All-Star team, I wonder: has anyone ever won the league award but missed out on a Topps trophy? I doubt it, but stranger things have happened on baseball cards (*cough* Glenn Hubbard *cough*). If you know of such shenanigans with the Topps All-Star Team rosters, please add a comment.


UPDATE: This mis-cut shows Munson on the printing sheet next to #54, the 1st series checklist.


Too bad #5 was one of the few cards missing from this collector's stack; looks like he had a tough time finding those 1970s stars.

Value: This card's popular, but you can find low-grade versions for $10. It's considered a key card for the 1971 Topps set.

Fakes / reprints: Topps reprinted this card for their "Archives" inserts into modern sets, so look for a glossier finish and foil stamp to distinguish them.

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

1970 Topps Baseball #5, Wes Parker

My dad, a lifelong Dodgers fan, turned 64 last week. I missed him on the day itself, so left a birthday voice mail with generic good wishes and a call back request. I steered clear of talking baseball, given LA's huge off-field issues with the McCourts and their looming, uncertain off-season.

Fast forward to last night, when my voice mail chirps with a response. Dad spent three seconds catching me up on the home front ("All is good here! Hope it's good there!") and then charged right into a recap of the Dodgers' supposedly lame-duck September, when they went a stellar 17-9.
"So first we knocked those evil Giants out of the picture and then gave those snakes (i.e., Diamondbacks) something to think about. Should've done more of that in July, but we'll take what we can get. And let me tell you about Matt Kemp..."
I think dad's ready for Spring Training 2012.


Wes "Mr. Steady" Parker turned in his own Matt Kemp-caliber season in 1970 by knocking around NL pitching (in a pitcher's park, during a pitcher's era) to the tune of a 133 OPS+ and finished fifth in MVP voting behind HOFers Johnny Bench, Billy Williams, Tony Perez, and Bob Gibson, not the worst group of guys to lose out to.


I'm a fan of Topps' multitasking cartoons, but they got the glove hand wrong, since Wes throws with his left. That, and 1969 produced a third Gold Glove, not the second. He grabbed six straight from 1967-72. That's two errors on one card back. Not very Wes Parker-like!

UPDATE: I also used this Wes Parker to design my own custom 1970 Topps card.

Value: 1970 non-star singles cost about a quarter.

Fakes / reprints: Topps reprinted stars from this set as vintage-style inserts for modern sets, so look for their glossier finish and "Archives" stamp to avoid confusion.

Monday, October 10, 2011

The Accidental Giveaway: NFL Panini Promo Stickers

Watched yesterday's Patriots/Jets game from a bar and stumbled across this Panini sticker sheet. It's the first of three promos planned for Sunday issues of the Boston Globe in October.


I'm mostly a baseball collector, so let me know if you'd like this sheet. Not sure if I'll come across others, so get in touch with Boston-area friends or collectors if you want to pick up the other sheets. (Being Boston, they'll probably have Brady, Welker, and a few other Patriots along with the guys like Newton and Tomlinson.)

1978 TCMA Arkansas Travelers Baseball #5, Joe Edelen

I'm not sure how today's photo came to be, given a card-maker's usual practice of posing players under bright sun or at least during daytime. This set, though, looks night-shot or trimmed down to player silhouettes over black backgrounds. I assume there's a good reason for the unusual light balance, even if just "it was at night or never."


This set carries over a 1977 design and precedes TCMA's leap to full color in 1979, which several teams used instead of black-and-white (see my Charleston Charlies #5 profile). Distinguish the two by their front labels, orange for 1977 and green for 1978. Former MLB manager Jim Riggleman appeared in the 1977 version, scan visible in Keith Olbermann's article "A Hairstyle Is Temporary; A Baseball Card Is Forever."


Looks like a McDonald's sponsorship helped pay the print bill for TCMA, at least in Arkansas. I lean on TeamSets4U.com for their year-by-year minor league team checklists; here's everything from 1978, including all 23 Arkansas Travelers (note that some numbers don't match up).

Value: This #5 cost a couple dollars on Beckett Marketplace. A few of Joe Edelen's teammates went on to make their name in the bigs; you might pay more for Tommy Herr, Leon Durham, and Terry Kennedy.

Fakes / reprints: Haven't seen any in the marketplace.

Friday, October 7, 2011

Two more player wantlists and a sketchy giveaway

Added two more wantlists to my player collection last night and posted links to all four on the blog sidebar, just below "Top 5 Posts."


Jamie Quirk caught and played utility man for nearly two decades in KC, Milwaukee, St. Louis, Chicago, Cleveland, Oakland, Baltimore, and New York (but mostly KC). He did a little of everything for everyone and switched to coaching after retirement, currently on staff with Houston (Jamie Quirk wantlist).


Spike Owen was my favorite Mariner during the 1980s and I was bummed when his Seattle tenure ended with a trade to Boston in 1986. Spike went on to play good-glove shortstop for Montreal, New York, and Anaheim. He continues in baseball as manager for the Texas AAA affiliate Round Rock Express (Spike Owen wantlist).

I've got a variety of low-grade vintage cards to trade for hits to my player collections; just leave a comment on their wantlist pages or send an email through my Google profile!

CONTEST: This pair of 1960s cards received a virtual gravestone rubbing, very sketch-like. First to identify the set, year, and players via blog comment wins them. (Please guess only if you actually need/want the cards. :-) Both are HOFers.


Thursday, October 6, 2011

David Segui Baseball Wantlist Added

Just posted my second player collection wantlist for former Oriole/Met/Expo/Mariner/Ranger/Blue Jay David Segui, son of original Seattle Pilot and Mariner Diego Segui.

David Segui (as a Met) photobombs a Will Clark card

David played in the heart of the junk wax era (1990-2004), so plenty of cards are out there! According to Beckett, I've filled in most of 1990-1999, but 2000 and up had so many cards it's hard to know for sure. I've got mostly low-grade vintage as trade material.

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

1975 Sussman West Palm Beach Expos Baseball #5, Mark Ewell

This is another of Neil Sussman's sets of Florida minor league teams, preceding the already profiled Fort Lauderdale Yankees from 1976 and 1977. All of Sussman's sets share this basic design, with black-and-white fronts and blank backs. Today's set numbering maxes out at 30, but two checklist variations bring it to 32 cards total.


This Mark Ewell picture's so completely grey, it begged for pastel Miami Vice revitalization.

YEAHHHHH!

So much cooler. That's a card that knows the thrill of riding in a convertible and busting South Beach drug dealers.

Value: This #5 cost $3 at MinorLeagueSingles.com, who supplied a bunch of my 1970s minor league cards. Few of Mark's 1975 teammates made the big leagues (team roster at B-R.com); best-known were Shane Rawley and Tony Bernazard, who might cost a little more. (As of writing, you can buy most of the set on eBay for $8.)

Fakes / reprints: Haven't seen any in the marketplace.

Monday, October 3, 2011

1970 Pittsburgh Pirates Baseball Autograph Cards #5, Dave Ricketts

Back in the 1980s, Seattle management and Mother's Cookies teamed up to create several years of Mariners team sets. Attendees received a small envelope of cards as they entered the Kingdome on scheduled "baseball card day" games throughout the season, or you could buy sets and albums in the stadium shop. I never felt flush enough for the full set, so did my best to trade for missing cards.

1985 Mother's Cookies Mariners #15, Jim Beattie

Jim Beattie generated Seattle's most interesting pose, given that he was a pitcher. Not sure if this a straight-up photo gag or they caught him in bullpen warm-up gear. Several other cities got the Mother's Cookies treatment in that era--any favorite cards from other collectors?

On the same theme but a generation prior, Pittsburgh sold sets of pre-autographed photo cards to fans throughout the 1960s and 1970s. Today's featured players wearing white 1970 home duds in an empty Three Rivers Stadium, which opened on July 16 of that year. Its 25-man checklist includes HOFers Stargell, Mazeroski, and Clemente, making set-building a challenge.

Card front (blank back)

I learned this 1970 Pittsburgh uniform, the "white home alternate," was MLB's first entirely synthetic model, down to its stretchy waistband and pullover jersey with no zippers or buttons. That means the synthetic jersey's middle aged! Next thing you know, it'll be riding around town in a new "mid-life crisis Corvette" and shooing teenagers off its Astroturf lawn.

Value: This #5 came in a group lot for $4; they're rare enough to make singles unpredictable. You might get lucky, like I did, and find one for $1. HOFs run $25 or more.

Fakes / reprints: Haven't seen any in the marketplace, but it'd be easy to fake valuable players like Clemente. Note these are oversized cards, approx 3.5" x 4.5", so larger than a normal card but smaller than a postcard.

Sunday, October 2, 2011

Wantlist added for Steve Garvey

This blog now hosts my Steve Garvey wantlist. It's been a long time in the making, close to 30 years! Here's one of my favorite obscurities.

1990 Michigan State #105

Not many vintage gaps remain, but thanks to our modern era's return to 70s and 80s players, more "new" Garveys hit the market each year.

2010 Topps Garvey signed bat barrel

Hadn't even seen that card before, so copped the scan from COMC.

I've got a couple dozen post-1990 Garveys, but there must be plenty more. Expect low-grade vintage in return, 1980 and before, as that's what I collect. If that's what you're seeking, check out the wantlist and let me know!